Electronic cigarettes

Electronic cigarettes (also known as e-cigarettes, electronic nicotine delivery systems – ENDS or ‘personal vapourisers’ -PVs) are battery powered atomisers which produce vapour by heating a liquid solution. The liquid solution usually contains nicotine with a mixture of propylene, glycol, glycerin and flavourings. Drawing air through the e-cigarette triggers the heater to create a vapour which is inhaled and exhaled the same way as smoke from conventional cigarettes. Producing nicotine vapour from a solution rather than by burning tobacco means that electronic cigarette vapour is free from some of the toxic chemicals that accompany nicotine in cigarette smoke. In Great Britain, 5.5% of people in 2017 said they currently used an e-cigarette, which equates to approximately 2.8 million adults in the population (Adults smoking habits in the UK 2017- Office for National Statistics). Action on Smoking and Health (ASH) estimates that approximately 1.5 million are ex-smokers while 1.3 million continue to use tobacco alongside their electronic cigarette use (May 2017).

We talked to people who had been using e-cigarettes for different lengths of time ranging from more than five years to two weeks. They all said that they used them to help cut down, or give up, smoking cigarettes (see our section on Motivations to quit).

Anthony decided to search for an alternative to conventional cigarettes when he developed a cough that kept him awake at night.

Age at interview 39

Gender Male

View profile

People also mentioned financial reasons for switching to e-cigarettes. Conventional cigarettes are expensive and people could save money when they changed to e-cigarettes (although clearly not as much as those who stopped altogether – see ‘Money and smoking‘). Anthony, who uses a type of e-cigarette that requires pre-filled cartridges rather than liquid re-fillers, said he is vaping the equivalent of twenty cigarettes per day so financially it does not make much difference.

Jai compares how much money he used to spend when smoking conventional cigarettes to how much he spends now on e-cigarettes.

Age at interview 43

Gender Male

View profile

People we talked to liked the fact that they could use e-cigarettes in some places where smoking was banned or discouraged. At work, people had replaced their break time cigarette with vaping.

Anthony found it easy to switch from conventional cigarettes to pre-filled e-cigarettes.

Age at interview 39

Gender Male

View profile

Jai calculates that he is smoking less with e-cigarettes than he did with conventional ones.

Age at interview 43

Gender Male

View profile

Vaping does not have the ‘hit’ of smoking a conventional cigarette and some people still smoked cigarettes when they could, at home in the evenings or when with friends who smoked. However, some people were surprised at how easily they had taken to e-cigarettes and how they had cut down on conventional cigarettes. Some clearly saw this as a stepping stone to giving up smoking altogether, seeing electronic cigarettes both as an alternative and a way to gain control over their smoking.

Days after she took up vaping, Debbie cut down from twenty five to five cigarettes a day. She doesn’t want to become dependent on e-cigarettes because her goal is to quit smoking and vaping.

Age at interview 51

Gender Female

View profile

Other people did not have immediate plans to stop and seemed content to replace some, or all, of their cigarettes with vaping. Finding different flavours and trying different types of vaping had contributed to some people’s enjoyment of the substitutes.

At first, Jai found it difficult to stick to e-cigarettes but now enjoys an aniseed flavour. He describes accessories that can make vaping more like smoking conventional cigarettes.

Age at interview 43

Gender Male

View profile

Rosanna compares smoking a conventional cigarette and an e-cigarette. She thinks that it is a question of habit forming and hopes that soon she will get use to vaping only.

Age at interview 56

Gender Female

View profile

Not all electronic cigarettes include nicotine; some simply produce vapour for inhalation, but these do not seem to be as popular. People we talked with have been reducing the nicotine dose and some would like to reached the minimum dose, while others planned to replace nicotine altogether and end up vaping just water.

By chance rather than choice Jai reduced the nicotine dose. Ideally, he would like to bring down the nicotine dose to zero and then, to stop smoking all together.

Age at interview 43

Gender Male

View profile

Among the people we talked with, only Debbie talked to her GP and local pharmacists before starting using e-cigarettes. More commonly, people found information online, or talked to a family member, or friends or colleagues who were already using e-cigarettes.

Rosanna’s son showed her information online about e-cigarettes and told her about his experience of using one. She also got information from the e cigarette store she used.

Age at interview 56

Gender Female

View profile

Debbie told her GP and pharmacists about her intention of using e-cigarettes and got two different opinions.

Age at interview 51

Gender Female

View profile

Recent research shows, ‘Respondents who reported having used an e-cigarette in their most recent attempt to quit were more likely to report still not smoking than those who used NRT bought over-the-counter or nothing.’**.

Debbie feels confident that she will be able to quit smoking cigarettes. Her mother died of lung cancer so she is aware of the risks.

Age at interview 51

Gender Female

View profile

Since 2016, e-cigarettes have been classed as medicines by the UK Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA), which mean that e-cigarettes are required to be manufactured to medicinal purity and delivery standards. In other words, they undergo rigorous tests, and are subject to proactive controls on advertising. This move has been widely welcomed by medical experts and officials, as tighter regulation will help control safety and efficacy. Until 2016 e-cigarettes are only covered by general product safety legislation, which meant they could legally be promoted and sold to children, and the ingredients and amount of nicotine contained within each e-cigarette could vary. People we talked with were aware that there is a lack of medical research and reliable information about possible long-term health impacts, although reasoned that e-cigarettes were bound to be less harmful than smoking. Jai and Anthony have used e-cigarettes for quite a while and commented on the health benefits they have noticed since replacing their cigarette smoking with vaping.

Anthony no longer coughs at night, nor does he need his asthma inhaler as much as he used to. He feels lucky to have succeeded in replacing cigarettes for what he feels is a healthier option.

Age at interview 39

Gender Male

View profile

The safety and long-term safety of e-cigarettes is currently a hot topic for researchers. E-cigarettes do contain chemicals and other toxins which are associated with an increase in the risk of developing cardiovascular problems and lung diseases and so should not be promoted as safe/risk free or for use by non-smokers. The World Health Organisation advise against using e-cigarettes indoors or in enclosed spaces, until the exhaled vapour is proven to be not harmful to bystanders although they do recognise that ‘ Switching from smoking tobacco cigarettes to using e-cigarettes – known as vaping – may reduce user harm, by supporting quitting or acting as a lower risk substitute. However, the degree of harm reduction is uncertain.’***

*Dockrell, M., et al., E-Cigarettes: Prevalence and Attitudes in Great Britain. Nicotine & Tobacco Research, 2013. 15(10): p.1737-1744.
**Brown, J., Beard, E., Kotz, D., Michie, S. and West, R. (2014), Real-world effectiveness of e-cigarettes when used to aid smoking cessation: a cross-sectional population study. Addiction, 109: 1531-1540. doi: 10.1111/add.12623
*** Bulletin of the World Health Organization 2017;95:540-541.

Complementary approaches to quitting

Many types of support are available privately as well as on the NHS. This section covers people's experiences of hypnotherapy, acupuncture and other self-help approaches...