Experiences with health professionals: General Practitioners (GPs)

GPs are frequently the first point of contact for people seeking help for mental health issues. Experiences with GPs varied amongst the people we spoke with. Most people consulted GPs for their emotional distress, particularly in the initial period when they were trying to understand what was happening to them and obtain a diagnosis. Only a couple of people saw neither a GP nor any other medical professional for their depression. People also looked to GPs for information about available treatments, prescribing antidepressant medication, and referrals to other health professionals.
Some GPs with a special interest in mental health provided counselling, along with pharmacological treatments. Many people had taken the opportunity to develop mental health plans with their GP and subsidised counselling sessions with a registered psychologist through the government funded ‘Better Outcomes in Mental Health Care’ programme or ‘Better Access to Psychiatrists, Psychologists and GPs’ initiative. A few people who had migrated to Australia mentioned appreciating GPs who spoke the same language or came from a similar ethno-cultural background as this was helpful in understanding cultural expression of emotional distress and norms around addressing such distress.
For most people, the gender and age of their GP was less important than the way they treated them as a patient. However, a few younger people emphasised seeing GPs that were ‘good with young people’. As Troy said of his GP, ‘we’ll go see him because he’ll know what he’s doing, and he was good and he was lovely and I’d go back to him any day’. Desirable qualities or aspects of GPs included’ a long-term relationship and awareness of their patients’ life circumstances and problems, listening and understanding, willingness to experiment with different medications and therapies, and treating patients with dignity. A few people appreciated GPs who were additionally qualified in mental health, as expressed by Debra who said: ‘You need a doctor maybe that’s got a bit of empathy, maybe done some studying in mental health as well’. Other important qualities mentioned were noticing signs, asking the right questions, and reassuring patients that depression can be treated, but it may take time to get better.
Some people had a long history of mental health issues, sometimes having more than one diagnosis. Over several years, they had been prescribed many different medications by their GPs and these experiences had not always been positive. One woman believed her initial treatment with a particular medication was unnecessary and made her feel dependent on it. Ron described being prescribed antidepressants by his GP when he was first diagnosed with depression in the 1980s, without being given any explanation about the condition or the medication. As he put it, ‘…he didn’t seem to want to hear me, “just take these pills”‘. Gabrielle recounted a past experience of a locum GP leaving her with a large quantity of antidepressants while she was breastfeeding and feeling suicidal.

Gabrielle described a GP she saw while experiencing perinatal depression who was both helpful and…

Age at interview 42

Gender Female

Age at diagnosis 23

View profile

It was also important for people’s experiences to be acknowledged and validated. Some people objected to being told by their GPs that they did not have depression when they believed they did, while others had the opposite experience of being diagnosed with depression and feeling pressured to take antidepressants when presenting for physical health problems.

Louise spoke about an experience of a GP who dismissed her worries about her depression returning…

Age at interview 45

Gender Female

Age at diagnosis 32

View profile

Belinda spoke about feeling stigmatised by a GP who insisted she was depressed then made…

Age at interview 35

Gender Female

Age at diagnosis 25

View profile

Some people had multiple health and allied health professionals involved in their depression care. In such cases, it was seen as important for the GP and other health practitioners to be ‘on the same page’ for the patient to feel comfortable about their treatment. This was not always simple to achieve however.

Debra described the process of bringing her GP and other mental health care providers into…

Age at interview 43

Gender Female

Age at diagnosis 34

View profile

Akello talked about feeling ‘let down’ when a GP she found very helpful left the practice. As she was not happy with the other GP she was referred to within the same practice, she searched for another doctor until she found one she was satisfied with.

After her GP left the practice, Akello considered herself lucky to find another one she liked…

Age at interview 45

Gender Female

Age at diagnosis 44

View profile

Some people we talked with described having had a friendly relationship with their GP prior to needing help for depression. This then became a barrier as they did not feel comfortable discussing certain matters related to their distress. Amelia said she had to stop seeing her long-term GP after an incident that left her with the impression that her GP also suffered from emotional distress, while Kim Hai did not want to admit to her GP her advice had been unhelpful.

Amelia talked about why she decided to stop seeing her long-term GP and said she now attends a…

Age at interview 51

Gender Female

Age at diagnosis 38

View profile

Kim Hai saw a GP from the same background who was also a friend. This made her reluctant to tell her that her advice had been unhelpful, so instead Kim Hai changed GPs.

Age at interview 59

Gender Female

Age at diagnosis 39

View profile

GPs being inflexible, overly authoritarian, patronising, or not listening to patients’ views about treatments were qualities or behaviours that people particularly disliked. In contrast, people who took a more active approach to their depression care and had a good relationship with their GPs reported engaging in honest discussions with them.

Colin valued his GPs willingness to engage in discussion about things he viewed as important.

Age at interview 74

Gender Male

Age at diagnosis 67

View profile

When people found a GP whom they liked, these relationships were described as a key source of professional support. Additional qualities in GPs people appreciated were compassion, a sense of shared life experiences (e.g. motherhood, migration, shared language or cultural background), extended consultation time when needed, trusting people’s judgements and decision-making ability, giving people choices about preferred treatments, and understanding what people go through in coming to terms with their mental health condition and diagnosis.

Rosie described her GP as her ‘lifeline.

Age at interview 48

Gender Female

Age at diagnosis 44

View profile

Stephanie appreciated being trusted by her GP and interpreted this as meaning her doctor saw her…

Age at interview 35

Gender Female

Age at diagnosis 29

View profile

Stewart emphasised the importance of GPs having an interest in and knowledge of depression. He…

Age at interview 46

Gender Male

Age at diagnosis 45

View profile

Suzi described her respect for her GP as instrumental in her not acting on her suicidal thoughts…

Age at interview 50

Gender Female

Age at diagnosis 21

View profile

Experiences with getting diagnosed

Almost all the people we talked with had been diagnosed with depression, most by their GPs and some by psychiatrists or psychologists. For some, non-mental...